
They weren’t all bad.
Looking back, there were some genuinely nice ones. Unfortunately, “nice” was never really the goal… even if I told myself it should be. The saying “nice guys finish last” didn’t come from nowhere. There was definitely evidence to support it, at least in my case.
I used to notice a pattern with myself. The more I spoke to someone, the easier things felt, the less I fancied them. If someone became too available, too quickly, they somehow lost their appeal. What started as interest would quietly turn into indifference… and then, inevitably, the friend zone.
That’s exactly what happened with James Bay*.
I met him in high school, just after my boyfriend had moved to England. I was heartbroken and, in true dramatic fashion, decided the only solution was to “move on” immediately.
James was Australian and, objectively, not exactly everyone’s type. But for some reason, I saw something in him. So I added him on MSN (a throwback in itself), and after a few weeks of chatting, we ended up at the same house party.
That night, I told him I liked him. We kissed. And then, just like that, he asked me to be his girlfriend.
Looking back now… what was I thinking?
The answer is simple. I wasn’t.
We spent less than a full evening together as an “official couple” before going our separate ways for the night, already making plans to meet the next day.
And then reality hit.
I woke up sober, to a stream of messages about how much he missed me and wished I was there. Less than 24 hours in. It was… a lot.
I remember sitting there thinking, this has to end.
He came over to a friend’s house the next day. We sat in the garden, his hand on my knee, and I just couldn’t bring myself to do it face-to-face. I completely shut down — something I now recognise as my go-to move when I didn’t like someone.
So I did what I always did back then. I waited until he left… and ended it over text.
His reply?
“What about all our memories?”
Memories. From less than a day.
At the time, I had absolutely no sympathy. When I didn’t like someone, I really didn’t like them, and nothing they said could change that.
Looking back now, I can see it more clearly. It wasn’t just about him being “too much”. It was about me not knowing how to handle someone actually being straightforward, available, and certain.
It didn’t excite me. It overwhelmed me.
And that’s probably where I was going wrong.

